The Cambridge Companion to American Science Fiction: Why American? Who American? What American?
![Image](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgLbx1w2-ihZQzrNbv10tsEKvz_5NSo42DAifSbcHfap-hauFT_tJzsMakZwQEk-ICV2O3OnATpYbm7A8hNP6GrodFolvBkkMQx4ooiVkn_6qy3HuEXu35nTguzREzzUFeu_O4d/s1600/Cambridge+American+SF.jpg)
Cambridge University Press recently released The Cambridge Companion to American Science Fiction edited by Eric Carl Link and Gerry Canavan, a sequel, of sorts, to 2003's The Cambridge Companion to Science Fiction edited by Edward James and Farah Mendlesohn. I bought the James and Mendlesohn volume at the first science fiction convention I ever attended, the Worldcon in Boston in 2004, and I think it's an admirable volume that mostly does its best to try for the impossible, which is to present a coherent overview of the history and scholarship of science fiction as a genre-thing (mostly in the Anglo-American mode). I have mixed feelings about the Cambridge Companion to... series, because the volumes often feel like grab-bags and pushmi-pullyus , a bit too specific for people looking for an introduction to the scholarship on a topic, a bit too general for people with knowledge of a topic. They often contain a few excellent individual chapters amidst many chapters that fe